Florida Think Tank Pushes to Scale Back Citizens Insurance
A policy research group is calling on Florida lawmakers to reduce the size of Citizens Property Insurance and restore its original role as a last-resort option for homeowners who can't find coverage elsewhere. The push comes as Florida's private insurance market shows signs of stabilization after years of turmoil. For anyone planning a move to the Sunshine State, this debate has real implications for what you'll pay to insure your home.
Florida's state-backed insurer, Citizens Property Insurance Corporation, has long been a safety net for homeowners who couldn't secure coverage through the private market. But after years of rapid growth — Citizens swelled to become one of the largest insurers in the state — a prominent think tank is now urging legislators to pull it back to its original, narrower purpose.
The group argues that Florida has made meaningful progress rebuilding a healthier private insurance marketplace, and that allowing Citizens to remain oversized undermines that recovery. Their recommendation is straightforward: tighten eligibility rules, push more policyholders toward private carriers, and restore Citizens to its role as a genuine fallback rather than a convenient first choice.
This kind of policy shift could reshape the insurance landscape for future Florida homeowners. If Citizens shrinks and private insurers absorb more of the market, competition could help stabilize — or in some areas, lower — premiums over time. However, in high-risk coastal zones where private carriers remain reluctant to write policies, reduced access to Citizens could leave some buyers with fewer options and higher costs.
Florida's insurance market has been one of the most closely watched issues for people considering a move to the state. Premiums have spiked dramatically over the past several years due to hurricane risk, litigation costs, and reinsurance pressures. Recent legislative reforms have begun to attract new private carriers back to Florida, which is the foundation for the think tank's argument.
You can read more about the proposal in the original report.
What this means if you're moving to Florida: The ongoing effort to shrink Citizens and strengthen the private insurance market may gradually improve coverage options and pricing stability, but you should still budget carefully for homeowners insurance and research carrier availability in your specific target area before committing to a purchase.
Source: Florida Politics · Summary by Move to Sunshine. Original article not reproduced.
Considering a move to Florida?
Tell our relocation concierge what matters to you and get matched to the right region, county, and city.
Talk to the concierge