Citizens Insurance Faces Hard Questions in the Florida Keys
Property owners in the Florida Keys got a rare face-to-face opportunity with Citizens Property Insurance leadership to press on a growing concern: just because a home is structurally sound doesn't mean it can be insured. The meeting highlighted the deepening tension between building safety standards and insurer risk models in one of Florida's most vulnerable coastal markets.
A town hall held at the Marathon Government Center brought together local homeowners, condo associations, and officials for a direct conversation with leadership from Citizens Property Insurance — Florida's insurer of last resort. The event was organized by Fair Insurance Rates for Monroe (FIRM), an advocacy group pushing for more equitable coverage terms in Monroe County.
At the heart of the discussion is a question that resonates far beyond the Keys: does a property being deemed structurally safe actually guarantee it will remain insurable? For many coastal homeowners, the answer is increasingly uncertain. Citizens has been tightening its eligibility requirements and pushing policyholders toward the private market as part of a broader "depopulation" effort — but private carriers have been retreating from high-risk coastal zones, leaving many properties in a difficult gap.
The Florida Keys present a particularly acute version of this challenge. Homes there face elevated hurricane, wind, and flood exposure, and insurance availability has become a genuine barrier — not just to buying, but to refinancing and selling existing properties. Condo associations, which are responsible for insuring entire buildings and common areas, have been especially hard hit by premium spikes and coverage restrictions.
For anyone considering a move to the Keys or broader Monroe County, this dynamic deserves serious attention before signing a purchase contract. Buyers should verify that adequate coverage is actually obtainable — and at what cost — before committing to a property. Lenders will require it, and the numbers can dramatically reshape the true cost of ownership.
For more detail on what was discussed at the meeting, see the original report.
What this means if you're moving to Florida: In coastal markets like the Florida Keys, securing homeowners insurance is no longer a formality — it's one of the most critical steps in your due diligence, and you should get a firm quote before making an offer on any property.
Source: Florida Keys Free Press · Summary by Move to Sunshine. Original article not reproduced.
Considering a move to Florida?
Tell our relocation concierge what matters to you and get matched to the right region, county, and city.
Talk to the concierge